Five Ways That the Romance Genre is Sexist Towards Men

Can I watch two people fall in love without a bunch of sexist problematic tropes? And to be clear, I do think the romance genre is sexist towards both men and women.

I’m covering the ways we women objectify men in this article, but stay tuned! I’m not forgetting about all the terrible internalized misogyny. That will be coming in a future post.

5) Financial Objectification

Men aren’t financial objects. Get out of here with all of that Billionaire/CEO romance. Like, dudes can’t even be regular rich in romance. It’s never “Taken by the Guy Who Invested in Bit Coins and Made a Decent Chunk of Change.” It’s always Billionaires.

Speaking as a feminist here, if we can talk about the ways that porn objectifies women, we can hold our own gender accountable for this BS.

And this trope really contributes to a culture that’s talking out of both sides of its mouth when it comes to men as providers. Women are unapologetically lusting after very rich dudes, while at the same time saying “Women should earn just as much as men. We should be independent and not need a man to provide.”

Hey, I’m so on board with that. Both people should contibute financially in a relationship. Neither should feel pressured to make more because of outdated gender norms. But can we say all of that while reading Billionaire books? I feel like no.

I want more romance with broke, hardworking dudes. I want more romance with retail workers, Uber drivers, accountants, IT help desk workers.

Men are not financial objects, and in a world that’s striving to be post-patriarchy, we have to give men a break. It’s just not fair to want to be treated as equals when it suits us, but also want to put the burden on men to provide.

4) The Player

The dude is always a player, or if it’s historical romance, a rake. He’s always banged a bunch of chicks. He’s super experienced.

Can I take this moment to give some props to season 23 of The Bachelor? I’m not embarrassed. I watch The Bachelor/Bachelorette. I know that’s not exactly the intellectual opinion to have, but I don’t give very many shits. I’m not fancy.

Anyhow, Colton is a virgin. That’s cool. Now, I do think it would have been better to lay off the virgin talk a teensy little bit. Just act like a dude being a virgin is a normal thing. But hey, they brought attention to the double-standard that is male versus female virginity. Pretty cool for such a mainstream show to do.

Females are almost always virgins in romance. So much so that when they aren’t, I’m pleasantly surprised and make a note of it. If that isn’t evidence of internalized misogyny, I don’t know what is.

In romance, the guy being experienced is painted as sexy, while the virginity of the female is held up as evidence of how desirable she is. Freaking gross.

There isn’t something wrong with a man if he’s a virgin. Men aren’t sex-crazed beasts, and they can choose to wait for all kinds of reasons, just like women can.

3) Creepy/Stalkery behavior

What’s up with the romance genre presenting creepy shit as sexy?

We’ve got Christian Grey following Ana on vacation, like a fucking creep. Like, dude, you weren’t invited. Get out of here. She wants to see her mom. If he wasn’t a hot, rich dude, I feel like the story would be less erotic/romance, more thriller, with Ana fighting to protect herself from this possessive, boundary-crossing creep.

I just read one Romantic Suspense that incensed me so much, I wrote a Goodreads review, Amazon review, and sent the author a message, demanding to know why her book is so rapey. I will let you all know if Cherry Adair ever gets back to me.

2) Lack of Diverse Body Types

We’re supposed to be such a body-positive world, but there is only one body type to be found in romance; full of muscles and TALL.

Poor short guys. They have to deal with the psychological damage that comes from being told they are failing at masculinity. To be a man is to be TALL. Also, ripped.

Here’s some r/nicegirls for y’all

So, being short means a guy is gay?….Like it’s fine to be gay. It’s also fine to heterosexual, male, and short.

This is our dirty laundry fellow women. Most of aren’t so brazen about it, but the attitudes the Nice Girls TM are displaying towards short guys aren’t all that unusual.

Let’s write men with all kinds of bodies in romance. Tall and short and ripped and skinny and fat and able-bodied and disabled and dark and light and….you get my point. It’s too damn homogeneous in the romance genre.

1 ) Broken Boy/Wounded Puppy

This one disgusts me more than any other. I’m so sick of male leads with emotional baggage. Just give me an emotionally healthy, well-adjusted male lead!

Christian Grey-Mommy issues and neglect

Hardin from Anna Todd’s ‘After’ series-severe trauma do to abuse and neglect

Caleb from ‘Chasing Red’-Daddy issues.

Looking at the sheer number of ‘cold and distant bad boys’ in the romance genre, you’d think we women can’t get off to a normal, chill dude. We can! But why aren’t those men more prevalent in the genre?

The romance genre is a problem ladies. We need to get our shit together. Men are not objects. They’re people like us.

Let’s start working together to get the romance genre to reflect that.

I’ll end by shouting out an erotic romance writer who really has her shit together. I know that I struggle to find non-asshole dudes in books with BDSM elements. Check out this fantastic lady and her refreshing twist on the BDSM sub-genre. Emotionally-intelligent empathetic men and badass women who can take care of themselves. A dom who is a sweetheart. My heart might just leak all the way out of my chest ❤

Check her out on wattpad. That site gets such a bad rap, but I think some of the most original content can be found there if you know where to look. PixieStormCrow. Super hot, without all the emotional abuse, financial objectification, or other problematic tropes.

More of this guys…please romance writers…more sweet men who communicate and engage with their partners in a healthy way.

Published by jyvurentropy

Writer, pessimist, true crime enthusiast, and chaotic neutral. I write a lot of books on wattpad. I also read a lot of romance, lurk on a lot of Columbine forums, and listen to a lot of Die Antwoord. I'm a weird human and I write books that reflect that.

5 thoughts on “Five Ways That the Romance Genre is Sexist Towards Men

  1. I mostly agree with you on these. I recognize all these tropes, and I don’t even read romance, and certainly no BDSM!

    5) This reminds me of the song “Livin’ On A Prayer.” A poor couple struggling to make it …. together. There used to be a “poor but happy because we have each other” trope … do you ever see that anymore, or has it gone the way of the dodo?

    4) Ha ha ha … Actually, most men kinda are sex-crazed beasts … but that doesn’t mean they all act on it. Lack of self-control or of appropriate socialization should be more of a red flag than a turn-on, right?
    Of course, the other huge problem with this trope is that for every “rake,” there must be a dozen non-virgin women who will not get to star in their own romance. I’m sure you will address this when you turn to the ways the genre is sexist against women.

    2) See Thor’s “dad bod” in Endgame. It was supposed to be a joke, but I thought he looked like a regular guy and still very handsome.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. “Certainly no BDSM”- oh gosh, we can see how you feel about that one. I mean, we can all have our preferences, but I think you should be careful about you phrase things. That comes across as kink-shaming and very r/notlikeothergirls to me.
      I like BDSM and I’m not embarrassed of it. I think the shame and stigma attached to BDSM probably contributes to some of the more problematic tropes in the BDSM genre, because women can’t openly talk about this fetish without other women coming out of the woodwork to give them side eye.

      I also think there’s a huge problem with saying most men are sex-crazed beasts. It’s super problematic for men and for women. All humans have a sex drive and that sex drive varies from person to person. Men aren’t “beasts” they aren’t animals. They are human beings who are just as wholly complex as women. And plenty of women have a huge sex drive, that doesn’t make them more masculine.

      I can tell the two of us have very different worldviews when it comes to gender. But I still very much appreciate you taking the time to read the blog and share your thoughts, even if I didn’t agree with them.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I don’t read anything that’s pornlike for personal reasons. Yes, I do think it harms women and men both. I wasn’t trying to shame you, but I guess I could see it might come off that way given that you’d just declared your reading preferences. However, please note that the comment overall was intended to be supportive of your post.

        I’m not familiar with the “r/notlikeothergirls” lingo. I don’t even know what the r/ means? Does that mean it appears on Reddit?

        Ditto with “sex-crazed beasts.” C’mon, that was somewhat tongue in cheek. I love men (especially my own man), but the longer I am around them the more I realize they are truly different.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Hey there. I don’t know whether you are still hanging around over here, but over on my blog, I have awarded you the Sunshine Blogger award (actually a tag). If you’re game, come on over and answer the questions. I am sure your answers will differ greatly from the other recipients’, which will make things interesting.

    Like

  3. Men have developed many of the same body issues women have had to deal with. Not as common but it is there. Some guys become obsessed with sculpting the perfect body with super low body fat and then there’s the whole manscaping thing. Guys will wax off everything south of the eyebrows and north of their toenails. Other guys just give up completely and become super insecure about their appearance.

    I don’t see this need to be obsessed over your body’s appearance to be a good thing for men or women. Just eat healthy, exercise regularly, and shower on a regular basis. You don’t need anything more. Everything else is vanity.

    Trying to compete with what you see on television magazines or movies will not help you find love or validation.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

By Hook Or By Book

Book Reviews, News, and Other Stuff

My Books-My World

A Journey through Life & Imagination with Books

Justified And Redeemed

"being justified freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus," Romans 3:24

The Hairy Purple Feminist

Feminism from a hormonally imbalanced and awkward black chick.

MG WELLS

✪ Enjoy The Journey!

WTVR.com

News, Weather, and Sports from WTVR Richmond

The Musings of a Beta Male

The story of my life. so far..

COME READ WITH ME

"As we express our gratitude, we must never forget that the highest appreciation is not to utter words, but to live by them" John F Kennedy

gnellis

Feminism and Fangirling

Literary-Luminesce

Sifting through life with the world of books and poetry.

The Electric Agora

A modern symposium for the digital age

The Orthosphere

Wherever an altar is found, there civilization exists - Joseph de Maistre

Literary Theory and Criticism

English Literature, Literary Theory, Linguistics, Film Theory, Media Theory, UGC NET JRF Exam Preparation, Novel Analysis, Research Papers Nasrullah Mambrol

D.A. Henneman - Author

Saraybooks LLC - Embrace the Journey

J.K. Ullrich

Fiction For Now

Jacob Robinson

The world moves towards convenience

Create your website at WordPress.com
Get started
%d bloggers like this: