EmOTioNAl LAboR: Just One of the Many Reasons I'm Parting Ways With Feminism

I’ve been calling myself a feminist since I was ten years old. I grew up in the heyday of the SpiceGirls. Girl Power. Girls are just as strong as boys. All of that. I believed in feminism with all of my heart.

Photo by Wellington Cunha on Pexels.com

Moving into my teenage years, I became more serious about my feminism. I started reading about issues like abortion and stem cell research. I read up on both sides of these arguments. I also became very interested in female sexual objectification in the media. I started reading books on the subject. My favorite was Jean Kilbourne’s “Deadly Persuasion.” I went on to watch her “Killing Us Softly” documentaries. I even became friends with an adjust college professor and finagled my way into attending a few Women’s Studies courses for free. She used to give me a ride from my high school to the campus and then home after. (She was a nice lady and I was a weird teenager).

Growing up in an abusive home and witnessing domestic violence firsthand, violence against women was another issue close to my heart. By college, I was reading Susan Brownmiller.

I loved being a feminist.

I believed in the ideology with all of my heart.

People often made jokes about what an “obnoxious feminist” I was.

I took it all in stride.

I loved being a feminist. Because feminism was important. Women, nay-the world, needed feminism.

But I don’t feel this way anymore, and the reasons are nuanced and many. I won’t be able to fit them all into one blogpost. I’d have to write a manifesto (and I’m not super interested in writing longform non-fiction).

Please understand my disenchantment with feminism can not be encapsulated in this one blog post. I will only be attempting to explain ONE of the many reasons I will no longer call myself a feminist.

And just to be clear (for anyone waiting in the wings to cry “If you believe in equality between the genders, then YOU ARE Feminist!!) I wasn’t the first one to say, “Hmmm….maybe I’m not a feminist.” Other feminists were.

Photo by Ian Joseph Panelo on Pexels.com

I do not believe in the patriarchy. I do not believe that women are systemically oppressed in the Western World. I do believe that men and women are equally capable and should have the same opportunities and privileges. This should mean I’m a feminist, right?

Wrong according to fellow feminists. Since I believe women already HAVE the same opportunities as men, because I do not believe men are unilaterally in all areas of life privileged over women (and in fact men are the disenfranchised ones in many areas, including homelessness, the education gap, higher suicide rates, mainstream genital mutilation at birth, among many MANY issues), because I believe that women already have equality, I have been told I am not a feminist.

I do not believe that as a white middle-class woman in America I am oppressed. I do not believe my gender holds me back at all. I am not a victim of anything. I used to believe I was. As I’ve grown older and my worldview has expanded with my life experience, I no longer feel this is the case. I’ve been told in no uncertain terms; if you do not believe in the patriarchy then you are not a feminist.

So…*shrug* I’m not a trad-con or anything. I used to think only weirdo traditional conservative women steeped in internalized misogyny were the types to say, “I’m not a feminist.” But the feminist movement makes no room for women who believe that women have already achieved equality. I’m not worried about leveling the playing field, because it looks plenty level to me. I’m only worried about maintenance. This statement alone got me banned from four separate online feminist communities:

“I don’t feel oppressed at all. I don’t think my gender holds me back, and women have all the same opportunities that men have

This brings me to the main topic of this post: silly little strawman issues. The fact that modern Western feminism is focused on issues such as the supposed lack of pockets on any and all female clothing (I have pockets on all my pants. Does feminism know about Target?), the “pink tax,” and my personal favorite: Emotional Labor; the fact that these are the current feminist talking points proves my point that women have already achieved equality.

Feminists use Emotional Labor as a catch-all for several different “issues” and I use that term as loosely as possible. They are as follows.

  1. The emotional work required in customer service jobs. Smiling and being nice.
  2. The imbalance in housework (I think technically it’s meant to be something separate, but I’ve seen a lot of feminists use the term in this way).
  3. The emotional work required to “run a household.” Some examples I’ve seen used are tasks such as keeping track of family members’ schedules, remembering birthdays, sending thank-you cards, etc.
  4. Listening to and supporting their husbands. Feminists claim that all heterosexual relationships are one-sided, and anytime a man goes to his partner to talk out his problems, it’s patriarchy.

Okay….deep breath…I’ll tear down these points in the order listed above.

  1. You can’t get a customer service job and then make surprised Pikachu face when *gasp!* you actually have to perform customer service. Yes, you have to smile and be nice to customers.
I have to smile and talk to customers! P-P-P-Patriarchy!

But let me add this, I used to be a Front End Supervisor for Home Depot. My department was about a 50/50 split males and females (and a couple of FtM trans people-we had a diverse department). You bet your ass the male cashiers had to smile and make nice with customers. It’s part of the job. Hey, I am all for paying customer service employees more. They are absolutely underpaid and undervalued, but don’t use this bullshit argument to make the case.

2. Don’t marry men who don’t care about you. And anyone who doesn’t listen to your feelings and strive to compromise doesn’t care about you. A husband who refuses to split the housework 50/50 is a symptom of a larger problem: an unhealthy relationship.

This a YOU problem, girl. Your relationship sucks.

Thankfully, you’re a feminist! A strong empowered woman, and you have the power to change this TODAY. You have complete control over what you accept in a relationship.

3. Oh! The labor of remembering schedules and making appointments! The oppression! Are men oppressed because they do most of the repairs and upgrades in Western households? If sending thank-you notes is EMotioNAL LABor, than what the hell is changing the wax ring on the toilet, cleaning out the gutters, special ordering storm doors, and keeping track of when the oil needs to be changed on the car?

I know some feminist is waiting in the wings to tell me it’s sexist to say men do the majority of that shit but like….come on. Gender roles are only still in effect when it’s convenient for you? Women are spending all their time on bullshit like sending thank-you cards and remembering birthdays (for real, why in the fuck?) and also doing all the home repairs and car maintenance? I feel like…no. And did I mention I was a manager at Home Depot for about half a decade. Yes, across multiple stores in multiple states. It might sound real pretty to say that women do everything men do (and hey, you want to build your own deck, go for it! I ain’t stopping you!) but I have seen the reality. Men still do all this shit.

I’m waiting for one of them to collect some data and slap a pretty name like “Emotional Labor” on the stress that comes with chasing down the contractor to find out where the hell the double-hung windows are, because that has to at least be in the ballpark of remembering birthdays, right? (I’m being sarcastic. That’s a lot more stressful. It is a known fact that contractors never answer their phones and special orders are always six weeks late minimum).

4. If you think listening to, supporting, and encouraging your man is “labor” than I’m not surprised he never does the dishes. You’re a shitty partner.

*Peace*

Published by jyvurentropy

Writer, pessimist, true crime enthusiast, and chaotic neutral. I write a lot of books on wattpad. I also read a lot of romance, lurk on a lot of Columbine forums, and listen to a lot of Die Antwoord. I'm a weird human and I write books that reflect that.

3 thoughts on “EmOTioNAl LAboR: Just One of the Many Reasons I'm Parting Ways With Feminism

  1. So, basically, fellow feminists kicked you out of feminism?

    I once shocked my Grandma by saying “I am not a feminist.” She thought this meant I didn’t think women ought to be able to vote or something. I just meant I didn’t think that marriage and family were an evil oppressive prison. The meaning of the word has certainly changed.

    I never heard of “emotional labor” before. I guess new terms keep coming up and I’m not visiting the right places online to keep up with them. Nor do I wish to. πŸ˜‰

    I do agree that the role that moms usually play in a household is a lot harder than it looks and is really undervalued. But by the same token, I think dads tend to worry a lot more about whether they will be able to protect and provide for their families than anyone realizes.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. lol I’m not sure they kicked me out, so much as made told me again and again that I didn’t belong. For a long while, I just ignored them. I knew I was a feminist. It didn’t matter to me that I didn’t hold the same views as other feminists. Because all feminism is supposed to be is believing that women are just as capable as men, and should be free to pursue all the same opportunities.

      But I’ve been banned from so many freaking online feminist communities. I’ve had so many IRL feminists call me a victim of internalized misogyny.

      I’m just really over it :/

      I’m going to call myself an egalitarian from now on.

      I agree with you that the meaning of the word “feminist” has changed a lot. It’s not just about women having the freedom to make their own choices for their lives anymore. As you said, feminism does a lot of crapping on women who make more traditional decisions (and I say that as a woman in my thirties with no children-just because I’m not traditional doesn’t mean I don’t support other women pursuing the lives that make them happy-and that’s what feminism SHOULD be).

      I totally agree with you that both men and women play a vital a role in the family. And even when it isn’t a family that adheres to traditional gender roles, if it’s a healthy partnership, then both people are contributing in their own way.

      For any women that are doing the hard work of being a mother/wife and not being recognized, then of course they should be appreciated by their families.

      But the way feminists address this is by bringing up this spector of “emotional labor” and acting like women do all the work and men do nothing and marriage itself is a form of oppression….It’s like, freaking A, when did feminism get so silly?

      The next thing I’ve got to tackle is the pockets lie they keep spouting. I really have no clue why so many feminists keep lying and saying female pants don’t have pockets. Maybe I’m the crazy one. Maybe I hallucinate all my pockets. They’re making me question myself lol

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Carries Book Reviews

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Book Nook

In search of a quiet place to hide with a good book.

For the Love of Science

The Books and Science of Josh Hedgepeth

Nikki Page Paintings

Painting, Books, & Thoughts of a Creative Mind

Seshat in Modern Days

Reading, Writing, and Other Literary Things

bexnbookx

Reading, Reviewing & Fangirling

Way Too Fantasy

Speculative fiction book reviews and more!

Reader and Proud

a place for bookworms

Writer's Treasure Chest

A blog for authors, about authors, written by an author

Dragons & Zombies

A reader lives a thousand lives before he dies. The man who never reads lives only one... (George R. R. Martin, A Dance with Dragons)

Space and Sorcery

Adventures in speculative fiction

Confessions of a YA Reader

Book blog. Mostly YA, but a little bit of everything.

Create your website at WordPress.com
Get started
%d bloggers like this: